UCPI Designated Lawyer Officers Core Participant Group v Sir John Mitting (Chairman of the Undercover Policing Inquiry) [2026] EWHC 1394 (Admin) (judgment here) 9 June 2026
Anyone who thought that disappearing abroad would provide a procedural invisibility cloak if an Inquiry Chair or Coroner wanted to hear their evidence is now going to have to think again. In this latest Divisional Court decision arising out of the Undercover Policing Inquiry the Chair, Sir John Mitting, has just successfully defended his issuing of a witness summons to a witness abroad. Consequently any cloak may now wear thinner than an overused metaphor if that witness ever wants to set foot in the jurisdiction again.
The judgment contains a detailed judicial analysis of compulsory attendance powers and territorial limits challenging the previous assumption that inquiries (and by analogy inquests) have no power to summons a witness who is abroad.
The dispute
The Chairman of the Undercover Policing Inquiry wished to hear oral evidence from a former undercover officer known as HN86. He had lived overseas for around 25 years, remained a British citizen, and although he provided a witness statement, he declined to give evidence either in person or remotely.[1] The Chairman served a notice under section 21 of the Inquiries Act 2005[2] requiring him to attend the hearings in London in July 2026.
When the issuing of the summons was challenged by way of judicial review the central question was framed as: does an inquiry have the power to issue a summons under section 21 of the Inquiries Act 2005 compelling a person who is abroad to attend in London to give oral evidence?